Choosing the Right Boat: A Comparison of Watercraft
Canoes and pirogues are open-topped boats that you sit on top of and paddle with a single-bladed paddle. Kayaks are enclosed boats that you sit inside and paddle with a double-bladed paddle. Rowboats are open-topped boats that you sit in and row with oars. Canoes and pirogues are often used for recreational paddling and fishing, while kayaks are more versatile and can be used for a variety of activities, including whitewater kayaking and touring. Rowboats are typically used for fishing and recreational boating
Canoes: The Classic Choice
Canoes are a great option for beginners due to their stability and ease of use. They’re perfect for leisurely paddling on calm lakes and rivers. Canoes are typically open-topped, allowing for easy entry and exit.
Words and images from a canoe builder.
Key features:
- Stable design
- Easy to paddle
- Open-topped for easy access

Pirogues: A Unique Experience
Pirogues (how to pronounce?) are similar to canoes but have a flatter bottom and wider hull, making them ideal for navigating shallow waters. They’re often used for fishing and exploring swamps and marshes.
Words and images from a Pirogue builder.
Key features:
- Shallow-draft design
- Wide hull for stability
- Perfect for exploring shallow waters

Kayaks: For the Adventurous
Kayaks are a more challenging option for beginners but offer a more immersive experience. They’re enclosed, providing protection from the elements and greater stability. Kayaks are perfect for exploring rivers, lakes, and even oceans.
Words and images from a kayak builder.
Key features:
- Enclosed design
- Greater stability
- Suitable for a variety of water conditions

Rowboats: A Classic Option
Rowboats are a classic choice for fishing and recreational boating. They’re typically larger than canoes or kayaks and require more physical exertion to paddle.
Words and images from a rowboat builder.
Key features:
- Larger size
- Requires more physical exertion
- Ideal for fishing and recreational boating

Choosing the Right Boat for Your Needs
When choosing a watercraft, consider the following factors:
- Your experience level: Beginners may prefer a more stable option like a canoe or pirogue.
- Your intended use: Are you looking for a leisurely paddle or a more adventurous experience?
- The type of water you’ll be paddling: Will you be on calm lakes, rivers, or oceans?
Rowing Through the Ages: A Brief Historical Guide to 4 Watercrafts
The Canoe
Canoes have a rich history dating back thousands of years. Their origins can be traced to ancient civilizations across various continents, including North America, Europe, and Asia. The term “canoe” is believed to be derived from the Taino language of the Caribbean, meaning “hollowed out log.” Early canoes were often made from a single tree trunk that was hollowed out and shaped. Over time, canoe-making techniques evolved, and materials such as wood, bark, and animal skins were used to create more sophisticated designs. Canoes have played a crucial role in the cultures of many indigenous peoples around the world, serving as a means of transportation, fishing, hunting, and trade. Today, canoes remain a popular recreational activity and a symbol of connection to nature and tradition.
Henry Hudson and Canoes
Henry Hudson, an English explorer, was a significant figure in the history of canoes. He led several voyages to North America in the early 17th century, exploring the Hudson River and Hudson Bay. Hudson used canoes to navigate the rivers and waterways he encountered, helping to establish European claims in the region.
The Pirogue
Pirogues are another ancient type of watercraft with a long history. Their origins can be traced back to indigenous cultures in the Caribbean and South America. The term “pirogue” is believed to be derived from the Arawak language of the Caribbean. Pirogues are typically characterized by their flat bottoms and wider hulls, making them well-suited for navigating shallow waters and rivers. They were traditionally made from wood, often using a single log that was hollowed out and shaped. Pirogues have played a vital role in the cultures of many coastal and inland communities, serving as a means of transportation, fishing, and hunting. Today, pirogues continue to be used in many parts of the world, both for traditional purposes and as recreational watercraft.
Jean Lafitte and Pirogues
Jean Lafitte, a French pirate and privateer, was a prominent figure associated with pirogues. He operated in the Gulf Coast region of the United States in the early 19th century and used pirogues to navigate the shallow waters of the bayous and marshes. Lafitte’s activities played a significant role in the history of Louisiana, and his legend continues to be celebrated in the region.
The Kayaks
Kayaks originated in the Arctic regions, where they were used by Inuit and other indigenous peoples for hunting and transportation. The term “kayak” is derived from the Inuit language, meaning “hunter’s boat.” These early kayaks were made from wood, animal skins, and bones, and were designed for maneuverability and stability in icy waters. The enclosed design of the kayak provided warmth and protection from the elements, making it well-suited to the harsh conditions of the Arctic. Over time, kayak designs have evolved, incorporating materials such as fiberglass and plastic. Today, kayaks are popular recreational watercraft enjoyed by people around the world, used for everything from fishing and touring to whitewater kayaking and racing.
Knud Rasmussen and Kayaks
Knud Rasmussen, a Danish explorer and ethnographer, was a significant figure in the history of kayaks. He conducted extensive expeditions to the Arctic regions of Greenland and Canada in the early 20th century, using kayaks as his primary means of transportation. Rasmussen’s explorations helped to shed light on the lives of the Inuit people and their reliance on kayaks for survival in the harsh Arctic environment.
The Rowboats
Rowboats have a long and versatile history, dating back to ancient Roman times. In Rome, rowboats were used for transportation, fishing, and military purposes. They were often used to transport troops and supplies across rivers and lakes, and they played a significant role in naval battles. The Romans were skilled boatbuilders, and they developed a variety of rowboat designs, including the bireme, a warship with two banks of oars, and the trireme, a warship with three banks of oars.
Rowboats continued to be used throughout the Middle Ages and Renaissance, and they played an important role in the exploration and colonization of new lands. European explorers used rowboats to navigate rivers and lakes, and to transport supplies and trade goods. In the 19th century, rowboats became more popular as a recreational activity, and they were often used for fishing and leisure.
Abraham Lincoln and Rowboats
Abraham Lincoln, the 16th President of the United States, was a significant figure associated with rowboats. He was known for his love of the outdoors and often spent time fishing and boating on the Sangamon River in Illinois. Lincoln’s connection to the river and his use of rowboats helped to shape his understanding of rural life and the challenges faced by farmers and river communities.
Keep them clean!
When it comes to choosing the right watercraft for your next adventure, there is no one-size-fits-all answer. It is important to consider your own needs and preferences when making your decision. However, no matter what type of watercraft you choose, it is important to remember to keep our rivers clean.
Here are two ways to help keep rivers clean while using your watercraft:
- Pack out what you pack in. This means bringing your own trash bag and disposing of it properly when you are finished with your trip.
- Do not use harmful chemicals or detergents in your watercraft. These products can pollute the water and harm aquatic life.
By following these simple tips, you can help to keep our rivers clean and healthy for generations to come.
F.A.Q.
- Kayak: Offers better maneuverability and stability in strong currents due to their narrower design.
- Canoe: Can be used in areas with strong currents, but may be less stable than kayaks.
- Pirogue: May not be the best choice for areas with strong currents due to their shallow draft.
- Rowboat: Can be used in areas with strong currents, but may be less maneuverable than kayaks or canoes.
- Pirogue: Ideal for shallow rivers due to their flat bottom and ability to navigate through shallow waters.
- Canoe: Can also be used for fishing in shallow rivers, but may be less maneuverable than pirogues.
- Kayak: May not be the best choice for shallow rivers due to their deeper draft.
- Rowboat: Can be used for fishing in shallow rivers, but may be less maneuverable than pirogues or canoes.
- Kayak: The most popular choice for whitewater paddling, as they are maneuverable and can handle rapids.
- Canoe: Can be used for whitewater paddling, but may be less stable than kayaks.
- Pirogue: Not typically used for whitewater paddling due to their flat bottom.
- Rowboat: Not typically used for whitewater paddling due to their lack of maneuverability.
- Canoe: Excellent for camping trips, as they can carry a lot of gear and are easy to portage.
- Kayak: Can be used for camping trips, but may have limited carrying capacity.
- Pirogue: Not typically used for camping trips due to their limited storage space.
- Rowboat: Can be used for camping trips, but may be less efficient for transporting gear.
- Pirogue: Often preferred for fishing in muddy waters due to their shallow draft and ability to navigate through shallow areas.
- Canoe: Can also be used for fishing in muddy waters, but may be less maneuverable than pirogues.
- Kayak: May not be the best choice for muddy waters due to their deeper draft.
- Rowboat: Can be used for fishing in muddy waters, but may be less maneuverable than pirogues or canoes.
Additional resources
- What’s Better – A Canoe or a Kayak? (youtube.com)
- MAKING MY PIROGUE (youtube.com)
- North American Canoe Country: The Classic Guide to Canoe Technique: Rutstrum, Calvin, Rutstrum,Calvin: 9780816636600: Amazon.com: Books
- Jean Lafitte Swamp Tours | New Orleans Swamp & Airboat Tours
- The Polar Explorer Who Documented Inuit Folk Tales (muchbetteradventures.com)